Court allows in-person sentencing for Tremonton man convicted of injuring four teens in DUI crash

Booking photo for Dustin Andersen (Courtesy: Cache County Jail)

LOGAN — The four Clearfield-area teenagers injured in a head-on collision in Logan Canyon last summer will have the opportunity to face the man convicted of causing the crash. The victims will each be allowed to speak at Dustin W. Andersen’s sentencing, after a judge ruled that the gravity of the crash merited an in-person hearing.

Attorneys for both sides participated in a virtual hearing in 1st District Court Monday afternoon, appearing by web conference. Prosecutors had requested the court allow the teenagers and others involved in the case to be present when Andersen is sentenced April 26.

Blue Kia after being hit head-on by a truck driven by Dustin Andersen, July 30, 2020 (Courtesy: Watson Family)

The 46-year-old Tremonton man was driving a Dodge truck northeast through Logan Canyon, US-89, on the night of July 30. Near milepost 468, the truck began to skid and lose control, veering into oncoming traffic and colliding head-on with a Kia.

The car that was travelling southwest, had four teenage occupants inside. Each of them were transported to the hospital in serious and critical conditions. One of the passengers in the backseat of the car, Sarah Frei, spent two and a half weeks in the ICU and went through 20 surgeries, including a double leg amputation.

Utah Highway Patrol troopers report Andersen was heavily intoxicated and speeding. He had a blood alcohol level of 0.229 after the crash. Tire marks from his truck were estimated to be over 250 feet in length, showing he was traveling above the 50 miles per hour speed limit.

Andersen accepted a plea deal March 15, pleading guilty to four counts of driving under the influence, two third-degree felonies and two class-A misdemeanors. In exchange for his plea, prosecutors dropped a remaining DUI charge.

Sarah Frei, left, and her friends Brooke Watson, Taevey Davis and Josh Harrison before they returned home to Syracuse. The four were all injured in a head-on crash in Logan Canyon with an allegedly drunk driver, July 30, 2020 (Courtesy: Frei Family)

During Monday’s hearing, the victim’s attorney, Heidi Nestel said the case has altered the lives of the four teenagers forever. And not allowing them to face Andersen together in-person would be prejudicial, limiting their rights.

Judge Brandon Maynard granted prosecutor’s request, allowing the teenagers and some of their family to be present for Andersen’s sentencing April 26. The hearing will also be broadcast by web conference to others wishing to view it.

Andersen was booked into the Cache County Jail after the crash. He was released hours later on bail after posting $17,245 bond, angering the victim’s families, who wanted him to remain incarcerated. He could be sentenced to up to 10 years in prison.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • Steven Hallowell April 13, 2021 at 5:12 pm Reply

    This person should spend the very maximum available to the court. Lives ruined! This is not something that is going to leave these kids! EVER!

  • Steven Hallowell April 13, 2021 at 5:14 pm Reply

    Guve him the maximum possible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.