Lure of crossover voting falling flat in Cache County

If elected, gubernatorial candidate Jon Huntsman Jr. pledges to address Utah's suicide epidemic by making treatment for mental illness more available and affordable statewide.

SALT LAKE CITY – There’s down and dirty politics afoot in the GOP gubernatorial race, but Cache County voters seem to be staying above the fray.

The campaign of Jon Huntsman Jr. is urging Utah Democrats and independent voters to register as Republicans in the hope that crossover voting will carry the tide for the mostly-liberal former governor in the upcoming GOP primary balloting.

Huntsman’s strategy is being aided and abetted by former Utah Democratic Party chairman Jim Dabakis, who is encouraging other Democrats to join him in throwing a monkey wrench into what he calls a “rigged election.”

But voters in Cache County don’t seem to be taking the bait, according to County Clerk Jill Zollinger.

Zollinger said that her staff isn’t seeing any evidence of significant numbers of Cache County voters changing their party affiliations as they prepare to mail out ballots for the upcoming Democratic and Republican primaries on June 30.

Huntsman is one of four candidates on the ballot in the GOP primary. His rivals are Lt. Gov. Spencer Cox, former Utah House speaker Greg Hughes and former Republican Party chair Thomas Wright.

Under Republican Party rules, their primary is a closed affair, with only registered GOP voters participating in that balloting. Dakakis says that limitation makes the primary a rigged election, since its outcome has determined who serves as governor since the 1980s.

“I believe everybody in the state ought to get into this fixed, rigged election,” Dabakis said, “to make sure that the best person gets elected governor of Utah, not just be passive and sit there and see who this small, small slice of state voters decide should be the leader.”

While it seems doubtful that crossover voting could determine the outcome of the GOP primary, Utah’s current voter registration statistics suggest that’s not a total impossibility.

As of May 26, Utah has nearly 1.5 million registered voters and slightly less than half of them are Republicans. Only about 220,000 voters are registered Democrats, but more than 475,000 voters are unaffiliated with either major party.

In the four-way race in the GOP primary, a candidate winning as little as 30 percent of the vote could secure the party’s nomination – and likely be guaranteed to win the governor’s office in the November balloting. Since Cox and Huntsman have been neck-and-neck in polling since January, a relatively small number of crossover voters could tip the balance in the primary balloting.

The most likely beneficiary of crossover voting by Democrats or unaffiliated voters would be Huntsman, who is widely regarded as the most liberal of the Republican gubernatorial candidates. The Huntsman campaign has been running ads on social media urging voters to ensure that they are registered as Republicans in order to vote in the upcoming primary.

Local voters’ lack of response to the crossover scheme may be an indication of low enthusiasm for Huntsman’s candidacy. While Huntsman’s campaign claims their candidate is a “proven, experienced leader” for troubled times, the former governor resigned from office early in 2009 just when Utah and the rest of the country were plunging into recession due to the collapse of the housing market.

Another factor may be that Cache County voters are showing more loyalty to local Democratic candidates than Dabakis.

Karina Brown of Nibley is the running mate of Democratic gubernatorial candidate Chris Peterson and Logan resident Darren Parry is in the running for the Democratic nomination to replace outgoing U.S. Rep. Rob Bishop in Congress.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • h2odoc781 May 31, 2020 at 9:21 am Reply

    Maybe they crossed over years ago? And have been voting to corrupt the primaries for years.

  • Carol Rosenthal May 31, 2020 at 4:54 pm Reply

    Mr. Schill:
    I respectfully encourage you to avoid inflammatory and biased language in your reporting; eliminate generalizations and suppositions that cannot be verified or substantiated; and avoid using quotes out of context that lead to inflammatory, biased reporting:
    1. “Down and dirty politics afoot” (inflammatory); “mostly-liberal former governor” (labeling intended to bias);
    2. “strategy is being aided and abetted” (inflammatory vs declarative language”). Possible rephrase: “strategy is supported by”
    3. “I believe everybody in the state ought to get into this fixed, rigged election,” Dabakis said (out of context, thus leading to bias and inflammatory effect. This comment was part of a larger response by Dabakis as he explained how the Republican primary rules prevent , currently, ~50% of the Utah population from voting in the state GOP gubernatorial primary );
    4. “Local voters’ lack of response to the crossover scheme may be an indication of low enthusiasm for Huntsman’s candidacy.” (“scheme”: changing affiliation is a legitimate, political right of a citizen not a “scheme”, which is inflammatory language in this sentence. You don’t know – nor does anyone else – what low rate of changing affiliation means, so it’s inappropriate to report your supposition without evidence. The effect is bias and “leading the reader”. It is sufficient to report – factually and without embellishment – that there is thus far low numbers of voters changing affiliation).

    Below you will find examples that help demonstrate how reporting must be factual, contextual, and unbiased – in language a reporter uses as well as the information he/she chooses to report, especially when the subject is politics.–including-an-unlikely-new-republican

    • DeeDee Polk May 31, 2020 at 9:08 pm Reply

      Thank you Carol; responsible, astute critique.

  • Fredrick Lewis June 1, 2020 at 8:48 am Reply

    Wow who knew that voting and having a voice in the political process was a “scheme” how dare some utahan’s throw a “monkey wrench” in the works by voting for the person who will be their governor? Also interesting that Trump supporter and former employee Huntsman is somehow labeled as “liberal” doesn’t CVD realize that if you’re trying to scare the masses away from voting for someone, using a word that you’re not able to define that you’re supposed to label them a socialist?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.